Health policy and politics are deeply connected, with each influencing the other in significant ways. The policies that govern healthcare—how it is financed, delivered, and regulated—are largely determined by who holds political power. It means that elections play a critical role in shaping the direction of health policy. The decisions made by those in power can lead to major shifts in how healthcare is provided and funded, affecting millions of people across the country.
When we think about elections, it is important to understand that the outcomes do more than just determine who will hold office. They set the stage for what kinds of healthcare policies will be pursued. Whether it is the president, Congress, or state governments, the people in power have the authority to make decisions that can either expand access to healthcare, improve its quality, or restrict it in significant ways.
The Impact of Elections on Health Policy
The results of an election can have profound consequences for healthcare policy. When one party gains control of the presidency and both houses of Congress, they can pass major healthcare reforms. For example, the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in 2010 was made possible by the Democratic Party controlling the executive and legislative branches. However, when political power is split between parties, it often leads to a deadlock where major legislative changes become difficult to achieve. In such cases, the president can still influence health policy through executive actions and administrative decisions, but these changes are typically more incremental.
At the state level, governors and state legislatures also have significant power over health policy. In recent years, we have seen states take the lead on healthcare issues, especially when there is gridlock at the federal level. It has been particularly evident in areas like Medicaid expansion and the regulation of health insurance markets. State-level actions can sometimes lead to innovative approaches to healthcare that can serve as models for national policy. Still, they can also result in significant disparities in healthcare access and quality between states.
Health Reform and Political Campaigns
Healthcare reform has been a pivotal issue in many U.S. elections. Over the years, different administrations have attempted to overhaul the healthcare system, with varying degrees of success. The concept of health reform generally refers to efforts to change how healthcare is financed, who is covered, and how care is delivered. These reforms can range from modest adjustments to sweeping changes that impact the entire healthcare system.
One of the earliest examples of health reform playing a major role in an election was in 1948 when President Harry Truman campaigned for universal health insurance. Although his plan was ultimately unsuccessful due to strong opposition from powerful interest groups like the American Medical Association, it set the stage for future debates on healthcare in the U.S. It wasn’t until 1965, under President Lyndon Johnson, that the U.S. saw significant health reform with the creation of Medicare and Medicaid, which provided health coverage to millions of Americans.
Fast forward to the 1992 election, where Bill Clinton’s campaign included a strong focus on health reform. Clinton proposed the Health Security Act, which aimed to provide universal coverage, but it was defeated in Congress. This failure highlighted the significant challenges of passing comprehensive health reform in the U.S., especially when facing opposition from various sectors of the healthcare industry. The controversy surrounding Clinton’s plan is often cited as a key factor in the Democratic Party losing control of Congress in the 1994 midterm elections.
The healthcare reform debate resurfaced in a major way during the 2008 presidential campaign, where Barack Obama campaigned on the promise of comprehensive health reform. It led to the passage of the ACA in 2010, a landmark piece of legislation that aimed to expand health coverage to millions of Americans. The ACA, however, faced fierce opposition, particularly from Republicans, who criticized the law’s individual mandate and the perceived overreach of government into the healthcare sector. The battle over the ACA continued for years, with numerous attempts to repeal it, most notably during Donald Trump’s presidency.
Health Care in the 2024 Election
The 2024 election presents a unique scenario. This election offers voters a clear choice between continuing on the path set by the Biden administration or returning to the policies championed by Trump.
During his time in office, Trump made several attempts to dismantle the ACA, including repealing the individual mandate penalty, which required most Americans to have health insurance or pay a fine. His administration also reduced funding for ACA outreach and consumer assistance programs, which made it harder for people to navigate the health insurance marketplace. Despite these efforts, Trump was unable to fully repeal the ACA, and the law remains a cornerstone of the U.S. healthcare system.
In contrast, the Biden administration has worked to strengthen the ACA by restoring funding for outreach programs and expanding subsidies to make health insurance more affordable. These efforts have led to record enrollment in ACA marketplace plans and historically low uninsured rates. The Biden administration has also focused on addressing rising prescription drug costs, most notably through the Inflation Reduction Act, which allows the federal government to negotiate the prices of certain drugs for Medicare beneficiaries.
As the 2024 election approaches, healthcare is once again a central issue. Trump has signaled that he would attempt to repeal and replace the ACA if re-elected, though details of his plan remain vague. On the other hand, democrats are expected to continue building on the ACA and pursuing policies that expand access to healthcare while controlling costs.
The Future of Abortion and Reproductive Health
Abortion and reproductive health are likely to be major issues in the 2024 election, especially in the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. This ruling has shifted the power to regulate abortion to the states, leading to a patchwork of laws that vary widely across the country. Some states have implemented strict abortion bans, while others have moved to protect and expand access to abortion services.
Trump, who appointed three of the justices who voted to overturn Roe v. Wade, has expressed pride in the decision and has stated that abortion policy should now be left to the states. This stance is likely to resonate with his base, but it may also galvanize opposition among voters who support abortion rights. Democrats, on the other hand, have vowed to protect access to abortion at the federal level and have taken steps to counteract state-level restrictions on reproductive health services.
The issue of abortion could play a significant role in voter turnout, particularly among women and younger voters who are more likely to support abortion rights. The outcome of the 2024 election could determine the future of reproductive health in the U.S., with significant implications for women’s rights and access to healthcare.
Addressing Prescription Drug Prices and Health Care Costs
The high cost of prescription drugs and healthcare services has been a longstanding concern for voters, and it is an issue that both Biden and Trump have addressed in different ways. During his presidency, Trump aimed at the pharmaceutical industry, criticizing the high cost of drugs and attempting to implement policies to lower prices. However, many of these efforts were either blocked by the courts or had limited impact.
One of Trump’s notable initiatives was a demonstration program that capped insulin co-pays for some Medicare beneficiaries. This policy was well-received by patients struggling with the high cost of insulin. Late in his presidency, Trump also introduced a rule that would have tied Medicare drug prices to those paid in other countries, but this rule was never implemented due to legal challenges.
Democrats have continued to focus on drug pricing, with the Inflation Reduction Act marking a significant step forward in this area. The law not only allows Medicare to negotiate drug prices but also caps out-of-pocket drug costs for Medicare beneficiaries. This legislation represents a major victory for those advocating for lower drug prices, but its full impact will depend on how it is implemented and whether it faces further challenges.
Looking ahead, the future of drug pricing policy remains uncertain. While Democrats are likely to continue pushing for more aggressive measures to control costs, Trump’s approach, if he returns to office, is less clear. He has expressed support for negotiating drug prices in the past but has also opposed similar efforts by Democrats. The 2024 election could have a significant impact on how the U.S. addresses the ongoing issue of high healthcare costs.
The 2024 election is shaping up to be a pivotal moment for U.S. healthcare policy. Voters are faced with a clear choice between continuing on the current path or pursuing a different direction. The outcome of the election will determine the future of key issues such as the ACA, reproductive health, and the high cost of healthcare.
While sweeping changes to healthcare policy are rare, the election could lead to incremental shifts that have significant consequences for millions of Americans. Whether it’s expanding access to care, controlling costs, or protecting reproductive rights, the stakes are high, and the decisions made in 2024 will shape the future of healthcare in the United States for years to come.
Discover more from Doctor Trusted
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
