The $320 Million Question: Is CMS Finally Giving Physicians Their Time Back?

Ask any physician or practice manager what they would change first, and “less paperwork” is usually near the top of the list. On November 5, CMS offered an answer, though mostly to hospitals, nursing homes, and other participating facilities rather than to individual physician practices.

CMS proposed a rule that would reform Medicare and Medicaid regulations it considers obsolete or excessively burdensome, following a review of the conditions of participation for all 21 provider and supplier types. Titled Cutting Administrative Requirements for Excellence in Patient Care (CARE), it is a proposed rule, not a final one. Nothing below is in force today, and the final text may differ.

What CMS Proposes to Remove or Simplify

Hospitals and critical access hospitals (CAHs)

  • Remove annual staff training requirements for transfer protocols and emergency services readiness. Both took effect on July 1, 2025, so they are in force today.
  • Remove the obstetric (OB) staff training and OB-specific QAPI requirements. Neither has taken effect yet; both are scheduled for January 1, 2027.
  • Clarify that CAH distance eligibility is judged against hospitals providing acute inpatient care, including other CAHs, rather than specialty-only hospitals.

Long-term care and other facility types

  • Remove the ongoing weekly respiratory illness data reporting for long-term care facilities, while keeping reporting during a public health emergency.
  • Remove requirements to educate staff about COVID-19 vaccines, offer them, and document it, including for ICFs/IID.
  • Remove the ombudsman notice for resident transfers related to emergent care.
  • Exempt existing LTC facilities from room occupancy and bathroom standards after a change of ownership or a lapse and restoration of certification. This is narrower than a blanket exemption.
  • For rural emergency hospitals, remove expired COVID-19 and influenza reporting and staff vaccination rules, and remove data reporting during a public health emergency. CMS expects no costs or savings for REHs.
  • Rescind three Medicaid payment transparency reports on the share of nursing facility and ICF/IID payments spent on direct care and support staff compensation.

Physical environment

  • Adopt the 2024 NFPA Life Safety Code and Health Care Facilities Code, and the 2022 Emergency and Standby Power Systems code, allowing additional sources of emergency power.
  • For several facility types, remove the requirement for an outside window or door in every patient sleeping area and the 36-inch windowsill rule for post-2016 buildings, deferring to the Life Safety Code’s egress requirements. Hospitals and CAHs would also lose the 60-inch sill rule for special nursing care areas in new buildings. This is a change to sleeping-room construction standards, not a repeal of natural light and ventilation for all patient care areas.

What Is Not Simply Being Deleted

CARE is not pure deregulation. It would replace the current OB training standard with new patient-rights requirements on birth tissue collection, covering informed consent and patient requests to retain or release tissue. These apply only to hospitals that furnish OB services and take part in birth tissue activities. That is new work for compliance teams.

CMS is also asking questions rather than proposing fixes. It seeks comment on physician supervision of CRNAs, which currently requires a physician to be immediately available, and on whether that policy should be retained or revised. It also seeks comment on PA and NP roles in long-term care, transplant program certification, and reducing hospital respiratory-illness reporting. For physicians, these questions may matter more than the headline number.

Where the savings land

CMS estimates average annual savings of approximately $320 million. The benefit is not evenly distributed:

Provider typeEstimated average annual savings
Long-term care facilities$142.6 million
Hospitals$123.2 million
Critical access hospitals$16.6 million
ICFs/IID$6.6 million

CMS separately estimates that rescinding the Medicaid payment transparency reporting would save providers about $30.4 million a year, with a small additional saving for states and the federal government.

For independent physician practices, the direct benefit is likely to be limited. Most provisions concern facility participation requirements, not routine billing, documentation or payer interactions. Any time returned to physicians depends on whether hospitals and other facilities rewrite their own compliance policies. A requirement CMS removes often survives as a hospital policy, a state mandate or an accreditor’s expectation.

Not everyone sees the changes as pure gain. LeadingAge welcomed dropping duplicative infection-reporting requirements but warned that rescinding the Medicaid transparency reports could lead to misguided policies and weaken visibility into funds being diverted from care. AHCA/NCAL welcomed ending pandemic-era weekly reporting.

What Administrators Should Do Now

  1. Map the proposals to your facility type. Hospitals, CAHs, REHs and long-term care face different changes.
  2. Don’t retire anything yet. The training requirements already in force remain in force until a final rule says otherwise.
  3. Plan for January 2027. CMS acknowledges that a final rule is unlikely before January 1, 2027, and says it will ask surveyors to focus on requirements not subject to imminent revision. That is a signal, not a legal waiver.
  4. Watch for new obligations. Hospitals with OB services should review how they handle birth tissue consent and release requests.
  5. Check state law and accreditor standards. CMS notes that facilities and accreditors remain free to keep their own training requirements.
  6. Comment by January 11, 2027. Comments on file code CMS-3484-P must be received by January 11, 2027.

CARE is a real step toward cutting paperwork, aimed at pandemic-era reporting, duplicative training mandates, and outdated building rules. But it is a proposal, and its largest savings flow to long-term care facilities and hospitals. Physicians will feel the effect only if those institutions pass the relief down.

Sources:


Discover more from Doctor Trusted

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.