ABA spending is rising sharply, and investigations are exposing weaknesses in billing oversight. The challenge for insurers and regulators is to stop improper payments without making children and families pay for failures in the system.
A $911,400 Bill, and a Much Bigger Problem
Carolina Lopez wanted help for her three-year-old son, not a financial crisis. According to a June 2026 investigation by The Wall Street Journal, she sought applied behavior analysis (ABA) therapy from a provider called The Perfect Child. Therapy began the previous July. In April she received a bill for $911,400.
Her insurer, Highmark, had stopped paying the provider’s claims. Lopez says Highmark told her the provider had not supplied requested documentation. The therapists stopped coming in March, and she has paused her son’s therapy. The Journal reported allegations of abusive billing involving The Perfect Child, including charges for services that were allegedly not provided. Highmark is investigating, and no outcome has been reported. The company did not respond to the Journal’s questions. These are allegations, not a legal finding against the provider or any other.
Lopez’s case shows what can happen to a family when billing and oversight fail: a parent who believed her child’s care was covered can end up holding the bill.
Spending Is Rising Faster Than Service Use
The growth has drawn attention from employers, insurers and regulators. According to the Journal, annual spending on hands-on autism therapy for about 40 large employers in the Health Transformation Alliance, covering 3.5 million people, doubled to $108 million between 2021 and 2025. The coalition attributes the increase to more patients, more hours of service and higher prices.
Separately, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) reports that Medicaid and CHIP spending on ABA rose 421% from 2021 to 2025, while the number of children with an autism diagnosis receiving services rose 67%.
These figures cover different populations and should not be compared directly. Nor does the gap between spending growth and service growth prove that the extra spending was improper. Higher spending can reflect treatment intensity, reimbursement, provider participation and individual clinical need. It does raise a fair oversight question: can payers establish that the services billed were appropriate, were delivered and meet payment requirements?
What Federal Audits Have Found
In a 2026 report, the HHS Office of Inspector General (HHS-OIG) found that Colorado’s fee-for-service Medicaid payments for ABA in 2022 and 2023 did not fully comply with federal and state requirements. The headline estimate was at least $77.8 million in improper payments. All 100 sampled enrollee-months included at least one claim line that was improper or potentially improper.
HHS-OIG recommended that Colorado refund about $42.6 million in federal funds and review an estimated $112.5 million in additional federal payments that might also have been improper. These are audit recommendations. They do not mean the additional payments have been found improper, or that refunds have been made.
The audit examined a sample, not every ABA claim in the state, and an improper payment is not automatically fraud. It can reflect weak documentation, a missed billing requirement or another compliance failure. Earlier HHS-OIG audits found at least $56 million in improper ABA payments in Indiana and at least $18.5 million in Wisconsin. Taken together, the audits point to recurring problems with documentation, billing and provider requirements, and they show why oversight has to examine the records behind claims, not just the amounts paid.
Where the Billing Model Creates Risk
ABA can involve several professionals, long treatment schedules, supervision and detailed records. That makes accurate documentation and billing controls especially important.
The risk is not limited to billing for a service that never happened. A claim can also fail to reflect the service actually provided, the staff involved, the time spent or the supervision required. A practice should be able to match any claim to the clinical record, session details, staff credentials and supervision documentation. If those conflict, the discrepancy needs to be investigated before it becomes a pattern.
The Journal also reported that Aetna’s investigations finding likely fraud or abusive billing by autism-therapy providers in its commercial business rose 300% between 2024 and 2025, and that the company expected a further 50% increase in 2026. These are the insurer’s own investigation counts, not a proven fraud rate for the sector.
What Insurers Should Look For, and What to Avoid
High utilization is not proof of wrongdoing. Useful review triggers include:
- Billed services that don’t match the records. Dates, duration, service details and personnel on the claim should line up with the documentation.
- Inconsistent or unsupported clinical notes. Records should support what was billed and meet payer and program rules.
- Credentialing or supervision gaps. The organization should be able to show that staff met qualification and supervision requirements.
- Repeated anomalies. Patterns across patients, staff or billing periods can justify a wider review.
- Unclear ownership of billing and documentation. When clinicians, supervisors, billing teams and outside vendors share the work, gaps appear unless responsibility is explicit.
These are indicators, not verdicts. A legitimate practice can show an unusual pattern for valid clinical reasons, and a documentation gap may call for a correction rather than a fraud finding. Reviews should be proportionate: identify the concern, examine the records, decide whether the claim met requirements, and separate an isolated error from a systemic problem or intentional misconduct. Weak controls let improper payments continue. Poorly targeted reviews delay payment for legitimate care.
The Cost of Overcorrection
Families are most exposed when oversight failures lead to sudden changes in coverage, network participation or reimbursement. A child may depend on an established treatment schedule. If a payer drops a provider or a state changes payment rules, the family may struggle to find another qualified provider or keep services continuous. Legitimate providers face added paperwork and slower payments as insurers tighten reviews.
None of that justifies ignoring suspected abuse. CMS’s August 2026 ABA toolkit addresses both program integrity and access. The agency states that it does not create new federal requirements, reduce Medicaid’s Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnostic, and Treatment (EPSDT) obligations, endorse a single treatment approach or direct states to limit access to medically necessary care. It gives states tools on individualized treatment, provider qualifications, supervision, payment methods and safeguards against improper billing.
What ABA Providers Should Review Now
Current scrutiny is a reason to check internal controls before a payer audit or claim dispute exposes the weak points.
- Reconcile claims with service records. Check billed dates, duration, service details and personnel against supporting documentation, and investigate discrepancies instead of letting them repeat across billing cycles.
- Verify staff qualifications and supervision. Keep current credential records and confirm that services meet payer and state requirements.
- Make the clinical rationale traceable. The treatment plan, session notes and billed services should form one coherent record that supports what was actually delivered, not just a template.
- Assign responsibility for compliance. Define who reviews clinical records, who verifies billing information, who monitors credentialing and supervision, and who resolves exceptions. Outsourcing billing does not remove the provider’s obligation to understand and monitor compliance.
- Monitor patterns, not just single claims. Periodic internal reviews can catch recurring documentation gaps or process failures. Findings should lead to corrective action and follow-up checks.
- Treat payer questions as a process. Answer documentation requests within the deadline, keep the records behind each claim and track recurring denials or audit findings. Repeated requests about the same issue may mean a process needs to change.
These steps cannot guarantee payment or prevent every audit. They can help a practice find weaknesses earlier and show that its billing is supported by the services delivered.
What the Money Pays For
ABA’s growth has brought more financial scrutiny to a service many families depend on. The evidence supports stronger controls. It does not support treating every provider, every costly treatment plan or every rise in utilization as suspect.
Payment systems have to do two things at once: find and fix improper payments, and keep medically necessary care available from qualified providers. For payers, that means testing claims against documented services and applying oversight that is targeted and consistent. For providers, it means treating documentation, credentialing, supervision and billing review as core operations. Success will be measured by whether payers can tell appropriate care from unsupported claims, and whether families can get care without paying for failures they did not cause.
Sources
- Christopher Weaver and Anna Wilde Mathews, The Wall Street Journal, “The Autism-Therapy Business Is Booming—and So Is the Billing Abuse,” June 2, 2026.
- CMS, “CMS Launches New State Toolkit to Protect Children with Autism, Strengthen Oversight of Applied Behavior Analysis Services,” August 4, 2026: https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/press-releases/cms-launches-new-state-toolkit-protect-children-autism-strengthen-oversight-applied-behavior
- HHS Office of Inspector General, “Colorado Made at Least $77.8 Million in Improper Fee-for-Service Medicaid Payments for Applied Behavior Analysis Provided to Children,” 2026: https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2026/colorado-made-at-least-778-million-in-improper-fee-for-service-medicaid-payments-for-applied-behavior-analysis-provided-to-children
- HHS Office of Inspector General, “Indiana Made at Least $56 Million in Improper Fee-for-Service Medicaid Payments for Applied Behavior Analysis Provided to Children Diagnosed With Autism,” 2024.
- HHS Office of Inspector General, “Wisconsin Made at Least $18.5 Million in Improper Fee-for-Service Medicaid Payments for Applied Behavior Analysis Provided to Children Diagnosed With Autism,” 2025.
Discover more from Doctor Trusted
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
